Religion Watch Archives

Monitoring Trends in Religion - From February 1990 to January 2016

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archives
    • By Issue
    • By Article
    • By PDF (2008-14)
    • By PDF (1985-97)
    • All Articles
  • Sections
    • Current Research
    • Findings & Footnotes
    • On/File
  • Google Search
You are here: Home / Archive / Pre-Vatican II church architecture revives

Pre-Vatican II church architecture revives

July 1, 2012 by Richard Cimino

Print-friendly

A revival of traditional-looking Catholic churches is under way in the United States, in some cases replacing the “ubiquitous Modernist structures of the previous half-century,” writes Michael DeSanctis in the Jesuit magazine America (May 28).

He adds that the anticipation of the conservative liturgical changes introduced by the Vatican in the last year may have spawned this architectural revival. Pope Benedict XVI’s “reform of the reforms” of Vatican II arrived in parishes several months ago in the form of changes in liturgical texts used during Mass. DeSanctis notes that “Perhaps the same impulse within the church that has caused such changes in ritual practice as the decanting of the blood of Christ from ‘cup’ to ‘chalice’—both literally and in the revised translation of the Roman Missal—is also behind the return to traditional architecture.”

Up until a decade ago, most church architects and design professionals “thought that dressing new structures in period costume did not square theologically with the Second Vatican Council’s demand for authenticity in every aspect of liturgical prayer.”Citing Pope Benedict’s address to the Roman Curia in 2005, “neo-traditionalist” proponents of these changes argue that the “strictly forward-looking or Modernist architecture prevalent since the council embodies a ‘hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture’ that is inimical to the church’s role as conservator of sacred memory.”

DeSanctis notes that the “neo-traditionalists stop short of proposing a one-size-fits-all pro-gram” of modifying Modernist structures. He cites St. John Neumann Church in Tennessee, which shows a cruciform plan that has largely been absent in church architecture since Vatican II and which tends to delineate distinct spaces for the laity and clergy. This church also breaks with the widespread practice of placing the tabernacle somewhere other than at the heart of the sanctuary. The central position of the tabernacle gives new visibility to the reserved blessed sacrament—an observance growing in popularity. DeSanctis concludes that “Whether buildings like these are compromises, aberrations or the first fruits of a full-blown ‘movement’ in American Catholic church design is still uncertain.”

(America, 106 W. 56th St., New York, NY 10019)

Print-friendly

Filed Under: Archive

Also in this issue

  • On/File: July/August 2013
  • Findings & Footnotes: July/August 2013
  • Singapore shows church–society tensions, but not culture wars
  • Western monks in Thailand preserving traditional Buddhist discipline
  • Japan’s Happy Science reaching Africa
  • Corruption charges in Korea’s largest church show megachurch turmoil, rethinking
  • Changing face of Reformed clergy in Switzerland
  • Foreign-trained preachers challenge local Islam in Albania
  • Iranian immigrants in Germany showing high Christian conversion rates
  • German circumcision controversy ignites debate across Europe
  • Current Research: July/August 2013
  • Canada’s immigrant clergy move outof ethnic enclaves
  • Secularist/skeptical movement facesgender imbalance and harassment charges
  • Academic rivalry, popularization challengebiblical archeology
  • DNA tests uncovering Jewish ancestryin Catholic populations
  • Jews rethinking where to draw the lineson Christian support for Israel
  • Growing acceptance of black Jewsby Jewish mainstream
  • Vitality and pluralism lead trendsin world Judaism
  • Reform rabbis more willing to officiate at interfaith weddings

Search the Site

Download the first issue of RELIGION WATCH (1980)

Download the first issue of RELIGION WATCH (1980)

Click on the image for downloading

© 2016-2023 Richard Cimino / Religioscope
·News Pro Theme · Genesis Framework by StudioPress · WordPress